| 2024 | John Bisco III | Alex Suarez | Jarred Peluso & John Phillips | Chase Walker & Matt Heineman | Michael Cobb |
| 2023 | John Bisco III | Ryan Hoffman | Ryan Hoffman | Michael Horvath | Alex Suarez |
| 2022 | John Bisco III | Andres Suarez | Andres Suarez & Kyle Kullman | Griffin Coyne | Michael Moniz |
| 2021 | Nick D'Amico | Garrett Glick | Garrett Glick | Nate Mikulski | Zion Frailey |
| 2020 | Nick D'Amico | Derek Bast | Derek Bast | Conor Howland | Adam Throne |
| 2019 | Nick D'Amico | Derek Bast | Derek Bast | Conor Howland | Adam Throne |
| 2018 | Nick D'Amico | Alec Huertas | Tim Healy | David Smith | Griffin Connelly |
| 2017 | Nick D'Amico | Evan Callahan | Thomas Bonilla | Alec Huertas | Jake Petro |
| 2016 | Nick D'Amico | John Yocum | Jared Dancsecs | DJ Blast | Alex Thomas |
| 2015 | Nick D'Amico | | | | |
| 2014 | Nick D'Amico | Nick Mazzella | John Yocum | Tom Byrnes | Jarrett Clymer |
| 2013 | Nick D'Amico | Brian Uliana | Brian Uliana | Jackson Zappas | Sean Wrobel |
| 2012 | Nick D'Amico | Edward Milisits III | Kevin Rold | Brian Uliana | Joshua Recke |
| 2011 | Nick D'Amico | Chad Frankenfield | Kevin Rold | Brian Uliana | Helsin Pujols |
| 2010 | Nick D'Amico | Greg Taylor | Patrick Devine & Greg Taylor | T.J. Luddy | Keith Goldoni |
| 2009 | Nick D'Amico | Alex Dalla Piazza | Frank Snyder | Patrick Devine | Alex Dalla Piazza |
| 2008 | Nick D'Amico | Ben Chambers | Ben Chambers & Mike Zanoni | Brendan Close | Chad Lear |
| 2007 | Nick D'Amico | Andrew Scheirer | Andrew Scheirer | Ben Chambers | Andrew Hartman |
| 2006 | Michael Hercik | Ryan Correll | Andrew Hartman | Jeffrey Mendoza | David Lengyel & Bradley Tress |
| 2005 | Michael Hercik | Ryan Correll | David Lengyel | Matt Williams | Tony Kapinas |
| 2004 | Michael Hercik | Thomas Baunach | David Fell | Andrew Holva & Matthew Williams | Jeremy Lee |
| 2003 | Michael Hercik | Jeremy Kametz | Matt Wicks | Tom Baunach | Ryan Broadhead |
| 2002 | Michael Hercik | Chad Correll & Ryan Snyder & Dave Kohler | Jeremy Kametz | Ryan Dalton | Kevin Bellas |
| 2001 | Fred Harris | Dave Koehler | Award Didn't Exist | Ryan Dalton | Bryan Jones |
| 2000 | Fred Harris | Ronald Orcutt | Award Didn't Exist | Thomas Mayock III | Kevin Jones |
| 1999 | Fred Harris | Christopher Roscher & Vincent Villani | Award Didn't Exist | Scott Garscar | Mark Pavlish |
| 1998 | Fred Harris | Raymond "Rocky" Gencarelli | Award Didn't Exist | Raymond "Rocky" Gencarelli | Alistair Durie |
| 1997 | Fred Harris | Matthew Kacanda | Award Didn't Exist | Joseph Volkert | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1996 | Ray Salabsky | Shawn Dougherty & David Mease | Award Didn't Exist | Raymond "Rocky" Gencarelli & David Pulieri | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1995 | Ray Salabsky | Ryan Dougherty | Award Didn't Exist | Michael Pavolko | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1994 | Ray Salabsky | Damon Moscato & Ryan Dougherty | Award Didn't Exist | Michael Pavolko | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1993 | Ray Salabsky | Matt Quartuch | Award Didn't Exist | Rich Clapp | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1992 | Ray Salabsky | Mark Miller & Timothy Transue | Award Didn't Exist | Award Didn't Exist | Award Didn't Exist |
| 1991 | Ray Salabsky | Michael Todaro | Award Didn't Exist | Award Didn't Exist | Award Didn't Exist |
